Better Know a Bagel: The New Broadway Cafe
JEWISH TIME PODCAST JEWISH TIME PODCAST SUBSCRIBE TODAY SUBSCRIBE TODAY
search
home page
Analysis

Better Know a Bagel: The New Broadway Cafe

David R. Cohen
By David R. Cohen January 19, 2016, 3:18 pm Edit

David R. Cohen is the former Associate Editor of the Atlanta Jewish Times. He is originally from Marietta, GA and studied Journalism at the University of Tennessee.

New Bistro set to open in late fall will replace Broadway Cafe in Toco Hills.
New Bistro set to open in late fall will replace Broadway Cafe in Toco Hills.

Ever since the new Broadway Cafe opened in mid-July, the restaurant has fed many a kosher-conscious bagel fanatic in the Toco Hills area. In this edition of Better Know a Bagel, we take a look at how its bagels stack up to Atlanta’s best.

As the only kosher restaurant in Atlanta to offer a full breakfast, Broadway Cafe had to be the next stop in my bagel-and-schmear-filled odyssey.

—

A visit to Broadway Cafe is not complete without the sliced Nova platter
A visit to Broadway Cafe is not complete without the sliced Nova platter

Atmosphere

With stylish wood-paneled walls, an inviting front counter, and tasty menu items such as falafel, baked ziti and an array of gourmet pizzas, it’s no wonder that Broadway has become a hangout for those in Toco Hills. Located across the street from the original Broadway Cafe on Briarcliff Road, the new spot somehow has both a modern vibe and a classic feel. Visit Broadway at lunchtime on a Wednesday and you might even witness an AJT editorial meeting in progress.

Verdict: 5/5 bagels

 

Bagels

Broadway Cafe isn’t strictly a bagel bakery, but it does make traditional, New York-style, kettle-boiled bagels that live up to their namesake. They boast a soft interior with a not-too-crispy coating. Broadway’s bagels lose points, however, on their toppings, which are too large and a little bit overcooked. Still, the wide variety of doughy discs, including chocolate chip, blueberry, onion and cinnamon raisin, should satisfy any bagel lover’s craving.

Verdict: 4/5 bagels

 

SpreadsBetter Know a Bagel: Broadway Cafe 3

From veggie schmear to whitefish, lox and PB&J, Broadway offers plenty of options for topping your bagel. Make sure to try the elegantly presented sliced Nova platter, which includes fresh cucumbers, tomatoes, red onions and a plentiful portion of lox. The cream cheese is a bit dense and tough to spread, however, so Broadway misses out on a perfect score here. The menu includes other kosher breakfast staples, including lox, eggs and onions; French toast; and breakfast pastries baked in house.

Verdict: 4/5 bagels

 

Overall

Although the new Broadway Cafe is not a devoted bagel deli, a visit to the restaurant is not complete without trying one of its bagels. Great atmosphere and food and a friendly staff are a successful recipe for this 6-month-old establishment managed by Avi Alzadeh. I highly recommend a morning visit for coffee and breakfast.

Verdict: 4/5 bagels

Previous Ratings

Next time: Brooklyn Water Bagel

read more:
comments